Op Ed: IRS Doesn’t Get Cryptocurrencies: Here’s Why

2019-12-12 19:27

After five long years, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) in the U.S. finally decided to release additional guidelines in October 2019 regarding crypto taxes. While the guidelines have brought some measure of relief by clearing up some important ambiguities, many say they’ve left more confusion behind. So what is the problem here really? Is it the fact that cryptocurrencies are a whole new asset class that regulatory authorities like the IRS have a hard time understanding? Or is it that the nature of certain crypto transactions is so complex that the existing tax framework is simply inadequate? 

Coin Splits: The Root of All Evil?

The IRS has finally talked in detail about “hard forks” — or Coin Splits as we like to call them at Bitcoin Magazine — and their tax implications, a subject that was ignored in previous guidelines and policy papers. It states that the “constructive receipt” of any new coins as a result of a hard fork will constitute taxable income. The IRS has built this entire guideline around the framework that crypto from the newly forked currency is “airdropped” into customers’ wallets, and this airdrop constitutes a realization event and is, therefore, liable to taxes. This means that the IRS treats coin splits like an event where a corporation distributes shares of another corporation to its shareholders, which is obviously a taxable event.

However, this takes away from a complete understanding of what a coin split/hard fork really is. While the IRS visualizes forked coins as “airdrops after a fork,” the technical reality is quite different. There is no actual airdrop of forked coins to customer wallets; in fact, the ledger is simply copied. 

What this means for practical purposes is that users do sometimes end up receiving forked coins they have no intention of ever using. Under the new guidelines, however, these users still have to pay tax on the receipt of such forked coins, which can be quite confusing. In many ways, a hard fork actually resembles a stock split or stock dividend, which doesn’t lead to a taxable event in most cases as the investor has merely subdivided their shares. So many experts were banking on this definition to be taken into account by the IRS while coming up with the guidelines, which simply didn’t happen. 

IRS Makes Crypto Mainstreaming a Little More Challenging 

Another disappointment that came from the guidelines was that the IRS clearly rejected the demand for exempting crypto transactions below a certain threshold from Capital Gains Tax. This means that people who spend their cryptocurrency on day-to-day expenses like bill payments and cups of coffee will have to keep paying crypto taxes on these transactions. The capital gain/loss, in this case, will be “the difference between the fair market value of the services you received and your adjusted basis in the virtual currency exchanged.”

This raises some questions about the potential for crypto to become mainstream in the future. The guideline will continue to discourage casual spending of crypto because most people wouldn’t want to take on more hassle come tax season. It may also discourage businesses from receiving crypto in exchange for everyday goods and services and could even become a hindrance toward crypto realizing its true potential as an alternate currency.

Specific Identification Can Reduce Your Tax Burden in a Big Way

It’s not all ambiguity and disappointment, however. With this guideline, the IRS has finally said that taxpayers can use both FIFO (First In First Out) and Specific Identification to calculate their cost basis. Specific Identification simply means that taxpayers can identify the coin they are disposing of and then use the acquisition cost of that particular coin to calculate their capital gains on the transaction. 

How This Works to the Taxpayer’s Advantage

So let’s say Person A buys 1 BTC in May 2019 at $2,000 and another in October 2019 at $3,000. They then sell the currency they purchased in October at $3,500. They now have an option — they can use either $2,000 as the cost-basis (based on the FIFO principle) or they can use $3,000 based on Specific Identification. In this case, it would make sense to use Specific Identification as the capital gain would be only $500 as opposed to $1,000 under FIFO. 

Now let’s suppose the May 2019 crypto was purchased at $4,000 instead of $2,000. In this case, it would make more sense for Person A to use FIFO to calculate their cost basis. Instead of a $500 gain, they would be able to book a capital loss of $500 instead. 

As you can see, this kind of flexibility gives taxpayers some room to plan their taxes systematically and minimize their tax burden. 

The Bottom Line

While there are some positives to this guideline, primarily around Specific Identification, other provisions, like the ones on hard forks, raise a lot more questions than they answer. As governments across the world start doubling down on crypto taxation and potential tax evaders, they will have to take much stronger steps to make sure that they’re creating guidelines that are unambiguous, comprehensive and technically sound.

This is an op ed by Robin Singh. Views expressed are his own and do not necessarily reflect those of Bitcoin Magazine or BTC Inc.

The post Op Ed: IRS Doesn’t Get Cryptocurrencies: Here’s Why appeared first on Bitcoin Magazine.

Similar to Notcoin - Blum - Airdrops In 2024

origin »

Operand (OP) на Currencies.ru

$ 0.00104476 (+0.00%)
Объем 24H $0
Изменеия 24h: 0.00 %, 7d: -6.01 %
Cегодня L: $0 - H: $0
Капитализация $0 Rank 999999
Доступно / Всего 0 OP

cryptocurrencies irs bitcoin get doesn recent according

cryptocurrencies irs → Результатов: 62


7 Hacks to Minimise Your Crypto Tax Liability

Have you had a great year with cryptocurrencies? Made the right trades at the right time and seen some hefty gains? Unfortunately, come tax season and the IRS is going to want a big chunk of your gains – they are already sending out warning letters! Given that crypto trading hasn’t been around for too […] The post 7 Hacks to Minimise Your Crypto Tax Liability appeared first on NullTX.

2019-9-17 13:05


US Congressmen urge IRS to provide clarity on cryptocurrency taxation laws in new joint letter

Government institutions in the United States of America have played a pivotal role in controlling the fate of cryptocurrencies and the digital asset market, in general. One of the main issues that lawmakers and government officials raise is the taxation on cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin [BTC] and Ethereum [ETH], which was discussed again in a recent […] The post US Congressmen urge IRS to provide clarity on cryptocurrency taxation laws in new joint letter appeared first on AMBCrypto.

2019-4-12 17:00


Crypto Assets And The IRS: Understanding Bitcoin Taxes And How To Calculate Profits And Losses

One of the most confusing things regarding cryptocurrencies is taxes. While there is a lack of any real regulations in most countries around the world, governments have still found a way to introduce crypto taxation, and take advantage of traders who are making a profit by dealing with digital currencies. Furthermore, those who have failed […]

2019-2-1 15:47


After Not Filing Taxes for 8 Years, John McAfee Claims IRS After Him For Cryptocurrencies

Earlier this month, John McAfee indicated online that he had not filed taxes for eight years and all but dared the IRS to come after him. Now, he says that he is on the run. He claims to be working and living on his yacht because the IRS is after him for his use of […] The post After Not Filing Taxes for 8 Years, John McAfee Claims IRS After Him For Cryptocurrencies appeared first on Coinjournal.

2019-1-25 22:49


Crypto Taxes 2019: How to File Your Bitcoin Profits and New Crypto Gains with the IRS

The last two years have brought a lot of popularity to cryptocurrencies, and the awareness of them has surged like never before in the previous decade of their existence. Countless investors started flooding the crypto market, and the coins' value grew as a result, which only served to attract new would-be investors. The prices were […]

2018-12-12 21:30


Фото:

US Representatives ‘Urge’ the IRS to Clarify Cryptocurrency Tax Guidance

On Wednesday September 19, a committee of US bureaucrats sent an open letter to the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) in regard to the way cryptocurrencies are taxed. The representatives’ letter directed towards IRS commissioner David Kautter wants the taxation office to publish provisional guidelines on how digital currency transactions and investments should be handled when US […] The post US Representatives ‘Urge’ the IRS to Clarify Cryptocurrency Tax Guidance appeared first on Bitcoin News.

2018-9-21 04:25


The evidence of a crack down on tax evasion and cryptocurrency: IRS find culprits at Lordsofcypto

Just recently, there is evidence of a crackdown on tax evasion and cryptocurrency. Agents are now learning blockchain technology to allow them to follow the money through the system. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) has gathered a specified team of criminal agents to establish tax evasion cases on users of cryptocurrencies like lordsofcrypto, a popular […]

2018-8-2 22:53


Фото:

IRS Launches International Crypto Tax Enforcement Coalition

The US Internal Revenue Service has launched an international joint task force focusing on cryptocurrencies in order to investigate crypto-related tax evasion and money laundering. Announced on Monday, the Joint Chiefs of Global Tax Enforcement (J5) will see tax enforcement agencies form the US, UK, Australia, Canada, and the Netherlands in join forces in order […] The post IRS Launches International Crypto Tax Enforcement Coalition appeared first on CryptoSlate.

2018-7-5 19:00


Фото:

Meet the Liberty Advisor Helping the Crypto-Rich Avoid Capital Gains

Since the incredible bull run last year, early adopters, and even people who invested in cryptocurrencies back in January 2017, have made an incredible amount of financial gains. In the U.S. some people who want to cash out a good chunk of money realize they’ll end up paying the taxman (IRS) a lot of money […] The post Meet the Liberty Advisor Helping the Crypto-Rich Avoid Capital Gains appeared first on Bitcoin News.

2018-7-3 04:20