Bancor Criticized For its Ability to Freeze Funds, Not for Exchange Hack

Bancor Criticized For its Ability to Freeze Funds, Not for Exchange Hack
фото показано с : btcmanager.com

2018-7-13 22:00

Bancor, a decentralized crypto exchange that raised $153 million in June 2017, has lost $12.5 million in ether, the native cryptocurrency of Ethereum, in a recent security breach. However, the blockchain protocol and its developers were criticized not for the theft of their funds, but for their ability to freeze funds using a centrally controlled system.

Start of Controversy: Freezing Stolen BNT

Almost immediately after the security breach was unraveled, the Bancor development team released a statement which claimed that 24,984 ETH, equivalent to $12.5 million, was withdrawn from the BNT smart contract. The developers clarified that the affected wallet is not a user wallet and user funds were not stolen throughout the entirety of the breach.

Controversy emerged when the Bancor team claimed that it had frozen the stolen BNT to limit the damage the breach could have caused to the Bancor ecosystem. The official statement from the Bancor team read:

“Once the theft was identified, we were able to freeze the stolen BNT, limiting the damage to the Bancor ecosystem from the theft. The ability to freeze tokens was built into the Bancor Protocol to be used in an extreme situation to recover from a security breach, allowing Bancor to effectively stop the thief from running away with the stolen tokens.”

The end outcome of the fund freeze was positive, given that the Bancor team was able to stop more funds from being stolen by the hackers. The issue with the statement of the Bancor team, especially amongst experts in the cryptocurrency community, is that a centralized party or arbitrator on Bancor is forced to decide whether an event or a case is considered as an “extreme situation” before freezing funds on the Bancor network.

The fundamental purpose of public blockchain technology is to enable the transfer of data in a truly peer-to-peer and trustless ecosystem. If there exists a centralized group of individuals or arbitrators that have the power to freeze funds, the decentralized nature of the project will inevitably be questioned by both developers and experts in the community.

Reaction From Experts

Jackson Palmer, the creator of Dogecoin and product lead at Adobe, said that the hack itself is not a key issue, but rather the built-in centrally controlled system of the Bancor network and other decentralized applications on Ethereum.

“The key thing here is not the hack itself – it is a fact the Bancor team could freeze funds. How many other “decentralized” DApps have a built-in kill switch that’s centrally controlled?” Palmer said.

LItecoin creator and former Coinbase director of engineering Charlie Lee echoed a similar sentiment as Palmer and said that the decentralized nature of Bancor could be questioned in this case. Lee noted:

“A Bancor wallet got hacked and that wallet has the ability to steal coins out of their own smart contracts. An exchange is not decentralized if it can lose customer funds OR if it can freeze customer funds. Bancor can do BOTH. It’s a false sense of decentralization.”

Emin Gun Sirer, a professor at the prestigious Cornell University, also condemned the centrally controllable system implemented by Bancor, stating that the network should have had integrated a solution in its core contract to avoid a sudden extraction of funds.

The post Bancor Criticized For its Ability to Freeze Funds, Not for Exchange Hack appeared first on BTCMANAGER.

Similar to Notcoin - Blum - Airdrops In 2024

origin »

Safe Exchange Coin (SAFEX) на Currencies.ru

$ 0.0054306 (-0.25%)
Объем 24H $1.742k
Изменеия 24h: 1.41 %, 7d: -8.63 %
Cегодня L: $0.0053635 - H: $0.0055227
Капитализация $6.099m Rank 99999
Цена в час новости $ 0.0239175 (-77.29%)

funds exchange bancor freeze ability criticized million

funds exchange → Результатов: 108


Crypto Isn’t Criminal Money: Binance Blocks Funds From Hacked Exchange

This week, the popular crypto exchange Cryptopia suffered the first major security breach of 2019, resulting in “significant losses” of crypto assets the exchange had stored.  Following the breach, social media users began tracking the movements of the stolen funds and alerted Binance CEO Changpeng Zhao that the funds had landed on Binance – the world’s.

2019-1-17 23:00


BitUN Blockchain Bank And Bitrabbit Exchange Announce Cooperation

Two leading blockchain technology players, BitUN and Bitrabbit have entered into a strategic cooperation agreement. The agreement will see both parties conduct long-term and in-depth cooperation on various aspects such as funds custody, funds settlement and user system to fully integrate the superior resources of technologies, products and services to provide the most secure and […]

2018-7-12 12:40


Фото:

Crypto exchange shows security breach and is down forr maintenance work

Decentralized cryptocurrency platform Bancor halted operations Monday, July 9, as it investigates what it calls a “security breach,” reportedly involving over $12 mln. No user wallets were compromised,” the tweet reads, continuing: “To complete the investigation, we have moved to maintenance and will be releasing a more detailed report shortly. User funds remain intact due

2018-7-9 21:23


Проекты из экосистемы NEO предупредили о возможном мошенничестве на бирже Bitpaction

Несколько экосистемных проектов на базе блокчейна NEO предупредили пользователей о возможных махинациях со стороны биржи Bitpaction и призвали вывести средства с платформы. Об этом говорится в блоге NEO.

2018-7-9 13:15


Scienceroot ICO

Scienceroot aims to improve the scientific and research community using blockchain technology. The goal is to create an ecosystem where anyone in the scientific community around the globe will have the ability to gather funding, interact, discuss research ideas, collaborate and in the end, publish their work through a more efficient, open and transparent platform.

2018-7-6 01:30


PlayChip ICO

The PlayChip is at the centre of an incentivised, blockchain-enabled sports community and gaming ecosystem. Following the migration of the PlayChip to the blockchain, holders of the PlayChip will be able to seamlessly transfer funds between the various sites accepting the token through our revolutionary PlayWallet, through which they will also be able to buy and sell the token directly via our partnered exchange, the PlayXchange.

2018-7-5 23:48


Фото:

Coinbase Custody is Now Live, But Will Institutional Investors Actually Use It?

As part of Coinbase’s initiative to facilitate institutional investment in the cryptocurrency market, the exchange’s Custody service is now live in the US and Europe.   Bringing in Big Money Coinbase Custody is a service which provides secure storage for crypto-assets for eligible financial institutions and hedge funds across the world.

2018-7-3 12:00


Global Pay Net ICO

Global Pay Net is an international financial platform that is based on the Blockchain technology. The company has been developing a unified service that allows each of its users to invest their money at interest, take out a loan, exchange funds and cryptocurrencies, keep their savings at a profit, and pay for goods or services using their own GLPN wallet.

2018-6-28 17:51