Proof-of-Stake Is Just an Excuse for the SEC; It Doesn’t Make Ethereum a Security

2024-5-1 16:58

Consensys has refuted the Securities and Exchange Commission’s (SEC) assertion that Ethereum could be considered a security following its transition to a Proof-of-Stake consensus mechanism. 

The software company, established by Ethereum co-founder Joe Lubin, filed a lawsuit in a Texas federal court against the SEC, arguing that the regulatory body is misapplying federal securities laws.

Proof-of-Stake Doesn’t Make Ethereum a Security

The controversy began when the SEC issued a Wells notice to Consensys, indicating plans to sue the firm. The notice was a part of the SEC’s wider investigation dubbed “Ethereum 2.0,” initiated on March 28, 2023. This formal order of investigation was approved by Gurbir Grewal, head of the SEC’s Division of Enforcement, allowing for the subpoena of parties involved in Ethereum transactions.

Despite Ethereum’s significant market presence and widespread adoption, the SEC’s investigation focuses on Ethereum’s Proof-of-Stake model. According to the regulator, the transition to this consensus mechanism might meet the criteria of the Howey Test, which determines if an asset functions as an investment contract and thus qualifies as a security.

Consensys argues that the SEC’s approach is inconsistent with previous guidance. In 2018, Bill Hinman, then-Director of Corporation Finance at the SEC, stated that Ethereum was not a security.

“Putting aside the fundraising that accompanied the creation of [Ethereum], based on my understanding of the present state of [Ethereum], the Ethereum network and its decentralized structure, current offers and sales of [Ethereum] are not securities transactions,” Hinman said.

However, the current SEC Chairman Gary Gensler hinted that Proof-of-Stake tokens could trigger securities classifications. This position reflects a pivot from the agency’s earlier stance and has injected uncertainty into the $2 trillion cryptocurrency industry.

In its lawsuit, Consensys claims the SEC’s current actions represent an unlawful overreach. The company emphasizes that Proof-of-Stake increases decentralization by enabling wider network validation and maintenance participation. 

This contradicts the notion that it could centralize control, which is often a characteristic of securities.

“The Proof-of-Stake, or the Merge upgrade, really is kind of the SEC’s hook for trying to say Ethereum is a security. But I think that’s just a surface level point. Nothing about Proof-of-Stake itself versus Proof-of-Work would make Ethereum a security. I think really that’s just grabbing at some explanation for the SEC,” a Consensys spokesperson told BeInCrypto. 

Read more: Proof of Work and Proof of Stake Explained

The SEC has not publicly commented on the ongoing case, maintaining a tight-lipped stance amidst the industry’s scrutiny. Meanwhile, Consensys hopes the court will provide a definitive resolution to Ethereum’s regulatory status debate. This a matter with far-reaching implications for the future of cryptocurrency regulations.

The post Proof-of-Stake Is Just an Excuse for the SEC; It Doesn’t Make Ethereum a Security appeared first on BeInCrypto.

Similar to Notcoin - TapSwap on Solana Airdrops In 2024

origin »

SherLOCK Security (LOCK) на Currencies.ru

$ 0.1387 (+1.71%)
Объем 24H $13
Изменеия 24h: 10.06 %, 7d: -33.06 %
Cегодня L: $0.1387 - H: $0.1387
Капитализация $0 Rank 3458
Доступно / Всего 0 LOCK / 4.969m LOCK

sec ethereum proof-of-stake security doesn make excuse

Источник: beincrypto.com

sec ethereum → Результатов: 126


Cardano Founder Addresses ETHGate Rumors: Did Ethereum Bribe The SEC To Go After XRP?

Cardano founder Charles Hoskinson recently gave his thoughts on whether the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) had given Ethereum a regulatory free pass as recent rumors suggest.    Cardano Founder Alleges Favoritism Toward Ethereum In an AMA session shared on X (formerly Twitter), Hoskinson mentioned that the Himman emails and other revelations expose the thought process of the SEC and show that there was unequal application, which he doesn’t see anything wrong with.

2023-10-12 12:30


СМИ выяснили причину разного подхода SEC к Ethereum и XRP

Причина, по которой SEC не считает Ethereum ценной бумагой, — это полностью построенная блокчейн-инфраструктура, работающая годы. Об этом сообщает корреспондент FOX Чарльз Гаспарино со ссылкой на собственные источники.

2021-9-17 10:42


Фото:

SEC: Ethereum — не ценная бумага

По мнению председателя Комиссии по ценным бумагам и биржам США (SEC) Джея Клейтона, со временем вторая по капитализации криптовалюта Ethereum могла утратить свой статус ценной бумаги. Об этом пишет The Block со ссылкой на письмо специалиста, представляющее официальную позицию ведомства по данному вопросу.

2019-3-13 09:50


В SEC считают, что Ethereum не обладает признаками ценной бумаги

Председатель Комиссии по ценным бумагам и биржам США (SEC) Джей Клейтон подтвердил, что Ethereum и подобные ему криптовалюты могли являться ценными бумагами в прошлом, но утратить этот статус со временем.

2019-3-13 20:15


Фото:

CBOE: запуск фьючерсов на Ethereum реален после заявления SEC

Президент Чикагской биржи опционов (CBOE) Крис Конканнон сообщил, что компания может добавить фьючерсы на Ethereum после того, как Комиссия по ценным бумагам и биржам США (SEC) отказалась присваивать криптовалюте статус ценной бумаги.

2018-6-16 22:11


Курс Ethereum положительно отреагировал на заявление SEC

Хотя многие не сочтут это объявление неожиданностью, высокопоставленный чиновник из Комиссии по ценным бумагам и биржам США подтвердил, что сделки с криптовалютой Ethereum не регулируются федеральными законами о ценных бумагах.

2018-6-14 21:15


В SEC не считают криптовалюту Ethereum ценными бумагами

Высокопоставленный чиновник Комиссии по ценным бумагам и биржам (SEC) США сказал, что криптовалюта Ethereum не является ценными бумагами в соответствии с федеральными правилами. Директор отдела корпоративных финансов SEC Уильям Хинмэн (William Hinman) заявил, что по крайней мере “структурированный так, как в настоящее время” ETH не будет регулироваться SEC как ценные бумаги. “Когда мы думаем о […]

2018-6-14 21:06


дальше еще 77 новостей →

Партнеры Currencies.ru

Реклама на Currencies.ru

Самое свежее на Currencies.ru

Long-Term Ethereum Investor Sells $12.7 Million in ETH

A long-time Ethereum investor transferred 4,153 ETH, valued around $12.17 million, to Coinbase, indicating possible intentions to sell. The post Long-Term Ethereum Investor Sells $12.7 Million in ETH appeared first on BeInCrypto.

Ethereum Market Turmoil: Analysts Predict Drop to $2500

Ethereum is at risk of falling to $2500 according to a recent investor advisory by 10X Research, citing weakened fundamentals and poor performance in the current market cycle. The post Ethereum Market Turmoil: Analysts Predict Drop to $2500 appeared first on BeInCrypto.

The Path to an Ethereum ETF Approval Is Complicated

Ethereum ETFs face regulatory hurdles similar to Bitcoin's. Approval could enhance legitimacy, adoption, and market participation, but SEC's caution underscores investor protection concerns. The post The Path to an Ethereum ETF Approval Is Complicated appeared first on BeInCrypto.

Ethereum Name Service Sues Unstoppable Domains Over Patent

ENS has officially challenged a patent held by Unstoppable Domains, claiming it uses their open-source technology. This legal action aims to ensure the web remains collaborative and open. The post Ethereum Name Service Sues Unstoppable Domains Over Patent appeared first on BeInCrypto.

SEC Chair Gary Gensler Misled Congress About Ethereum

During a House Financial Services Committee session, SEC Chair Gary Gensler avoided clear answers on Ethereum's status, leading to accusations of deception and a potential shift in regulatory approach for cryptocurrencies.